Editorial Policies

1. Policy on Authorship and Contributorship

The Journal of Gastronomy and Cuisine adheres to the authorship criteria established by the ICMJE (International Committee of Medical Journal Editors). An author is considered to be someone who meets all of the following four criteria:

  1. Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work; or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data (e.g., recipes, techniques, historical or sociological analyses, nutritional data).

  2. Drafting the work or revising it critically for important intellectual content.

  3. Final approval of the version to be published.

  4. Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.

All individuals who have contributed to the work but do not meet the criteria for authorship (e.g., support in dish preparation, writing or editing assistance, photographers whose images are not the central focus of the study, or sponsors who provided ingredients or materials) should be listed in the "Acknowledgements" section. Correspondence will be maintained with the designated author.

2. Complaints and Appeals Procedure

The Journal of Gastronomy and Cuisine takes all complaints and appeals very seriously. Any complaint regarding the editorial process, published content, or the conduct of authors, reviewers, or editors should be addressed in writing to the Editor-in-Chief at the following email address: editor-rgc@academiaculinaria.org.

All complaints will be investigated in a fair, confidential, and timely manner. The Editor-in-Chief will assess the situation and may consult with the editorial team or advisory board. A substantive response to the complaint will be provided within a maximum period of 4 weeks, explaining the decision taken or the actions to be implemented.

In the case of an appeal against an editorial decision (such as the rejection of a manuscript), authors must submit a detailed written justification, specifying the specific reasons for the appeal. The case will be re-evaluated by the Editor-in-Chief and, if necessary, by one or more members of the editorial committee who were not involved in the original decision. The resulting decision on the appeal will be final.

3. Handling Allegations of Research Misconduct

The journal defines research misconduct as plagiarism, fabrication or falsification of data (e.g., survey results, chemical analyses of food, deliberate incorrect historical attributions), unjustified authorship, or any practice that seriously deviates from accepted ethical norms. Upon suspicion of misconduct, the Editor-in-Chief will initiate an investigation procedure following the guidelines of COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics).

The process will include:

  1. Gathering evidence and requesting explanations from all involved parties.

  2. Consultation with the editorial committee and, in serious cases, with the authors' affiliated institutions.

  3. Taking appropriate measures, which may range from a correction or retraction of the published article, to a ban on submitting future works for a specified period, and notification to the relevant institutions.

The confidentiality of all parties will be maintained during the investigation.

4. Policies on Conflicts of Interest

All participants in the publication process (authors, reviewers, and editors) must declare any potential or real conflicts of interest that could influence their judgment. Authors must include a conflict of interest statement in the manuscript, detailing any financial support, sponsorship (e.g., from food brands, restaurants, or equipment companies), personal affiliations, or relationships that could be perceived as bias.

Reviewers and editors must decline to participate in the evaluation of a manuscript if conflicts of interest exist (e.g., a recent or current employment relationship with the authors, direct competition in a specific culinary field, a close personal relationship). The journal is committed to publishing conflict of interest statements or declaring that none exist.

5. Policies on Data Sharing and Reproducibility

The Journal of Gastronomy and Cuisine promotes transparency and reproducibility in research. Authors are strongly encouraged to share the data supporting their results (such as survey datasets, interview transcripts, chemical analyses, or detailed procedural sequences) in open-access repositories (e.g., Zenodo, Figshare) whenever possible and in accordance with ethical and privacy standards.

Authors must include a statement on data availability in the manuscript. It is highly valued that methodologies (e.g., culinary techniques, historical research processes) are described in sufficient detail to allow for understanding and, where applicable, replication of the study or technique.

6. Policy on Ethical Oversight

For research involving human subjects (such as tastings, surveys, sensory studies) or animals, authors must declare that the study was conducted in compliance with international ethical standards (e.g., the Declaration of Helsinki for human studies, or institutional/national guidelines for the use of animals in food production). The manuscript must include the name of the ethics committee that approved the study and the corresponding protocol number.

In studies involving traditional recipes or indigenous knowledge, authors are expected to demonstrate a commitment to ethics and the appropriate acknowledgment of source communities. The journal reserves the right to request ethical approval documents and will reject manuscripts that do not meet these requirements.

7. Policy on Intellectual Property

Articles published in the Journal of Gastronomy and Cuisine are distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY) license. This license allows others to share, adapt, and build upon the work, even for commercial purposes, provided appropriate credit is given to the author and the original work.

Authors retain copyright of their work and grant the journal the right of first publication. Authors may deposit the published version of the article in any institutional or thematic repository without restrictions. For graphical elements (photographs, illustrations), authors are responsible for obtaining the necessary permissions and ensuring their correct attribution.

8. Options for Post-Publication Discussions

Constructive post-publication dialogue is welcomed in the field of gastronomy and cuisine. Readers can comment on and discuss published articles through:

  • Letters to the Editor: Substantial comments on published articles may be submitted as "Letters to the Editor." These will be reviewed by the editorial team and, if approved, will be published alongside a response from the original authors, fostering enriching academic debate.

These mechanisms encourage the correction of errors, clarification of points, and ongoing academic and professional discussion.

9. Policies on Corrections and Retractions

The journal adheres to COPE guidelines for the correction of errors and the retraction of articles.

  • Errata (Corrections): Will be published when minor errors are detected that do not affect the conclusions of the work (typographical errors, errors in affiliations, etc.).

  • Corrigenda (Rectifications): Will be published when significant errors are detected in the methods, data, or results that do not invalidate the main conclusions (e.g., an error in a measurement or cooking time that does not alter the final outcome of the study).

  • Retractions: A full retraction of an article will be processed in cases of proven scientific misconduct (plagiarism, data fabrication, serious errors that invalidate the results and conclusions). The retraction will be published clearly, explaining the reasons, and will be linked to the original version of the article.

All corrections and retractions will be handled transparently to maintain the integrity of the academic and culinary record.